The DEFINITIVE isekai teir list

So uhh.. I'm boutta get cooked. Heavy statements I made in the list for some.

I'm going to skip past the entire slop section because you all know why I put all those anime there. There should be no arguments, and that is objective.

Tensura: Hot take, but true. Tensura might actually be the most overrated anime of all time because sweet brother of lord what do people see there different from slop? Tensura is the literal definition of serving rotten food on a golden plate.
The characters? Stupid asf or only for plot convenience. The plot? predictable. The antagonists? SOME OF THE SLOP TIER ANIME HAD BETTER ONE'S. LIKE EXPLAIN ME WHY MARIABELL, THE SUPPOSED GIRL WHO CONQUERED EARTH, DIED THE WAY EVERY OTHER OPPONENT DID- OVERCONFIDENCE.
And the worldbuilding? Overrated. And there are many reasons. Worldbuilding should nor be helpiing the MC become more powerful, it should challenge him. And this is just one of many reasons.

SAO: S1 part 1 was good... then it kinda fell off. Part 2 was extremely predictable. S2 is overhated th. I saw no actual reason why it's so hated.
And now, ALICIZATION. This was good. The idea? Orignal. The execution? Sweet. And this season removed all rumors that Kirito was a slop protag.


Tsukimichi, Land of Leadale and Killing slimes: Heaviy carried by their comedy rather than actual writing. But I still feel like they deserve to be atleast above Sheild Hero and Spirit Chronicles.

Overlord: I mean, anyone who has watched will agree? Ainz is the most complex character upto now. And the execution for the anime was perfect.


Grimgar: Alright hear me out HEAR ME OUT ALRIGHT. Look, Grimgar is good... it just has no S2. The best parts about the story are supposed to be in S2, so for now, it stays there. Sorry Grimgar fans.


Ascendance of a Bookworm: This is a slight overrated anime. It had potential but omg the MC feels like she's not moving the plot, but instead the author is making her do actions to progress the plot. Am i tweakin? The anime isn't bad, it just has too much unused potential.


Dating sim: Orignal idea, Orignal MC and great comedy. Need I say more? S2 was kinda underwhelming for me tho.


Log Horizon: This anime is orignal in all ways. The enemy being boredom instead of a demon is unique and the worldbuilding is underrated. I'm sad that this is on hiatus. It deserves more seasons.



Eminence in Shadow: people don't get this but shadow is peak written. Why? it's orignality and perfect execution. The typa story this tries to tell is genuinely so different, and it works. that anime doesnt need peak characters or plot, Cid is carrying it all.


NGNL: Self explanatory. If you'se seen it, you agree. Simple. If it had more seasons, it would be peak tier.


Isekai Ojisan and Konosuba: Both are there for their comedy.



And that's it. uhh, the entire thing is objective and may only change if new seasons were to come.
Note: Please take a moment to read the comment rules before posting.
21 Comments
You must be login to post a comment